Croker-Rhyne Co., Inc.

Main Page  |   Philosophy  |  Current Recommendations  |  Newsletter Archives
Contact Us

                                  

 

 

December 20, 2025

 

Cotton is a roaring Buy

Relative to the way this market moves,

July Call Options are dirt, dirt cheap

 

If you told me, “You can take one position, then leave town and not see it for the next six months,”…NO QUESTION…this “2 &1” would be it. From a straight up 100% statistical standpoint, going back for decades, it does not EVER get any better than this recommendation in two critical respects. One, if I’m wrong, I should be able to recoup 100% of what I have on the table…And two, if I am right, the average potential gain should be of a sizeable percentage. Of course, both of those outcomes are based on 30 years (actually 50) of data and it is obviously possible for this year to be the first exception…thus resulting in losing up to every dollar you have invested. BUT I WILL TAKE THESE ODDS…Irrespective of my market opinion, from an analytical standpoint, I’ll repeat: I JUST DON’T THINK IT GETS ANY BETTER THAN THIS.

 

I HAVE BEEN BULLISH COTTON DOWN HERE FOR A WHILE NOW…BUT CONSIDERING ANY NUMBER OF STANDPOINTS…I AM NOW ROARINGLY SO…ESPECIALLY IF YOU TAKE MY ADVICE AND POSITION OUT INTO JULY…USING “UNITS” OF 2 CALLS AND 1 PUT TO DO SO…WHY? BECAUSE THE HISTORICALLY BASED MATH SUPPORTING THE APPROACH IS UNDENIABLE.

 

JULY COTTON MOVES…AND MOVES BIG…YEAR AFTER YEAR AFTER YEAR…PRETTY MUCH FOR AS LONG AS I HAVE BEEN IN THIS BUSINESS.

 

I know that charts, and tables, and historical data can put some of you to sleep but I urge you to take the time to “get” my point with the table that follows here…which basically documents the high probability that this market, which has been laying here dead in the water for 18 months, is about to do SOMETHING, and most likely it will be BIG.

 

 

TOTAL MOVEMENT, UP OR DOWN, AWAY FROM THE MID-DECEMBER CLOSE OF JULY COTTON

                   BETWEEN DEC 15 AND THE CONTRACT EXPIRATION IN JULY 

               

Dec 15 close

Percent below

Dec 15

Percent above Dec 15

Greatest per cent change

2025

71.41

-13.1

+.7

-13.1

2024

81.17

-16.4

+26.4

+26.4

2023

81.25

-6.0

+10.7

+10.7

2022

102.14

-1.3

+52.7

+52.7

2021

77.00

-1.7

+25.0

+25.0

2020

68.87

-30.0

+7.4

-30.0

2019

81.34

-25.9

+.1

-25.9

2018

76.74

-1.29

+25.7

+25.7

2017

71.90

-2.59

+21.2

+21.2

2016

64.71

-16.0

+2.7

-16.0

2015

61.86

-4.8

+10.1

+10.1

2014

82.27

-9.4

+17.1

+17.1

2013

76.88

-1.6

+22.5

+22.5

2012

85.67

-22.8

+16.3

-22.8

2011

123.47

-.4

+70.0

+70.0

2010

76.19

-9.3

+14.39

+14.39

2009

45.56

-7.3

+35.3

+35.3

2008

68.90

-8.49

+37.2

+37.2

2007

56.89

-17.6

+8.19

-17.6

2006

54.70

-17.7

+8.6

-17.7

2005

43.75

-.1

+31.6

+31.6

2004

72.35

-35.8

+7.8

-35.8

2003

54.80

-12.1

+11.1

-12.1

2002

40.12

-18.1

+16.6

-18.1

2001

68.53

-45.3

+1.0

-45.3

2000

52.33

-4.8

+24.4

+24.4

1999

63.26

-24.5

+1.79

-24.5

1998

69.16

-9.9

+20.4

+20.4

1997

77.87

-9.6

+1.4

-9.6

1996

83.59

-17.4

+7.8

-17.4

1995

84.45

-2.1

+36.4

+36.4

 

Quite obviously, the big point here is what you see in the highlighted column…that going back to 1995, between now and expiration of the July contract, Cotton has averaged a 25% move, either up or down, away from its Dec 15th close. During 17 of those years, the average move up was 28 cents…and in 14 of those years, the average move was down 22%...and only ONE year, of -9.6%, which was not in double digit percentages.

 

WITH JULY AT 66 CENTS ON DECEMBER 15TH, A 25% MOVE WOULD BE ABOUT 16.5 CENTS…ONE WAY OR THE OTHER…WHICH WOULD BE FAR MORE THAN ENOUGH TO HAVE THIS RECOMMENDATION RECOUP THE ORIGINAL INVESTMENT…OR REALISTICALLY BE ABLE TO SCORE SOMETHING LIKE A 400% GAIN.

 

 

And the MASSIVE spec short in Cotton still keeps this market, in my old hack opinion, totally, totally primed for an upside explosion…

          

HOW TO BUY IT…

 

Quite honestly, during the past year, I got away from using the Both Sides Strategy, which I have forever believed/KNOWN is the best way to position in the futures markets. In fact, two of my personal wall reminders regarding trading (of 8 total) are:

 

IF YOU ARE NOT WILLING TO BUY BOTH SIDES, DO NOT DO THE TRADE.

 

LOOK FOR RANGE TRADE 2&1 SETUPS THAT PUT YOU IN A POSITION TO WIN BIG. THERE IS NO BETTER TRADE.

 

And that is what I have here in Cotton…and if you can see what I trying to show you as to why I am making this recommendation…I absolutely see the “2&1” as the way to do this, as, if Cotton does go lower, you can recoup 100% of the funds invested, and then you can reposition at even lower prices…And on the flip side, the potential dollar gains shown below are very real when Cotton does go up, which it WILL. But you do have to be there when it does…

 

 

You have no idea how bearish the industry wide sentiment is…which IS what you basically have had at every commodity market bottom in history…where low prices, and laying there forever just convinces the whole trading world that “there’s no way it’s going up from here.”

 

My view is that very strong hands have been quietly accumulating Cotton for the past year…And with this market having a 50 year history of almost routinely going from being “on its ass” to leaping 30-50 cents higher, I THINK THAT IS WHAT WE ARE GOING TO SEE IN 2026…quite possibly beginning right out of the gate. In other words, 2025 was “nowhere,” and 2026 will be exactly the opposite.

 

Another rule…Be enthusiastic when no one else is.

 

Contact me if you want to know more…

 

Thanks. Enjoy you holidays.

 

Bill

 

770-425-7241

866-578-1001

 

All option prices in this newsletter include all fees and commissions. All charts, unless otherwise noted, are by Aspen Graphics and CRB.

 

FUTURES TRADING IS NOT FOR EVERYONE. THE RISK OF LOSS IN TRADING CAN BE SUBSTANTIAL. THEREFORE, CAREFULLY CONSIDER WHETHER SUCH TRADING IS SUITABLE FOR YOU IN LIGHT OF YOUR FINANCIAL CONDITION. PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS. THERE IS NO GUARANTEE YOUR TRADING EXPERIENCE WILL BE SIMILAR TO PAST PERFORMANCE.

 

The author of this piece currently trades for his own account and has a financial interest in the following derivative products mentioned within: Cotton