Croker-Rhyne Co., Inc.

Main Page  |   Philosophy  |  Current Recommendations  |  Newsletter Archives
Contact Us

                                  

 

 

September 9, 2025

 

This newsletter addresses Interest Rates and the Stock Market, but before diving into what I think is EXTREMELY pertinent research, here’s a quick update on today’s Limit Down Close in Cattle.

 

Last week, both Feeder Cattle and Live Cattle had their first weekly reversals lower in six weeks. Is this it? On no news, they were sliding lower every day from Monday thru Friday last week…And then started this week, again on NO NEW, with both contracts in the tank, INCLUDING 9.25 CENT ($4625 PER FUTURES CONTRACT LIMIT DOWN IN FEEDERS.

 

As I have repeatedly pointed out, the Cattle market is more LOADED with Spec Longs than at any time in history (by miles)…and that when the break comes, there will be no attributable news to “justify” it as, per 50 years of history, they pretty much just go straight, straight down…And oh, yeah, I KNOW there are a TON of people out there thinking, “They’ve done this before. They’ll go right back up,” or, “This is just a correction. The cattle just ain’t out there.” And this is, as it is at EVERY top, is going surprise the you-know-what out of all of them.

 

JUST AN AVALANCHE OF LIQUIDATION IS COMING…and I’m sorry, but a whole country full of cattlemen who have blindly bought calves and steers up here at the most insane prices EVER are about to get blasted.

No telling what today’s limit down close will bring tomorrow…so it’s useless to post any option quotes today. DO know this, I believe, is just the 2nd week of a 6 month move…so no…you haven’t “missed it.” But if you have thought about getting on, I’d say go ahead and call me and GET IT DONE…

 

      BUY THE 10 YEAR NOTES

     BUY TREASURY BONDS

 

I  am both right and wrong about the markets…But one thing I “know” is that: WHEN YOU KNOW THE WHOLE SPECULATIVE WORLD IS ON ONE SIDE OF THE FENCE, AND I DON’T CARE HOW STRONG THEIR “LOGIC” APPEARS TO BE…YOU BET IN THE OPPOSITE DIRECTION.

 

Or to quote one of the greatest traders ever, “Start by assuming the market is always wrong, so if you copy everybody else on Wall Street, you're doomed to do poorly.”

 

I HAVE NEVER EVER SEEN WALL STREET SPECULATORS AS ONE SIDED IN THE MARKETS AS THEY ARE RIGHT NOW IN VIRTUALLY ALL OF THE INTEREST RATE FUTURES CONTRACTS. IN BLACK AND WHITE (ACTUALLY RED AND GREEN ON THE CHARTS BELOW), THEY ARE MONSTOUSLY SHORT UNITED STATES TREASURIES, IN MINDBOGGLINGLY RECORD NUMBERS, MEANING THAT THEIR BET IS THAT NOTE AND BOND YIELDS/RATES WILL BE GOING HIGHER.

 

I AM TAKING THE OTHER SIDE. I BELIEVE THAT THE 5 YEAR NOTES…AND THE TEN YEAR NOTES…AND THE TREASURY BONDS…ARE ALL SCREAMING, SCREAMING BUYS.

 

I HOPE you can decipher what these next four charts are saying…

 

TWO YEAR NOTES

 

FIVE YEAR NOTES

 

TEN YEAR NOTES

 

LONG TERM TREASURY BONDS

 

At a minimum, with all of these markets having been consolidating for a LONG time, some sort of truly directional move is very much overdue…

 

Aside from my STATISTICAL observation that EVERYBODY is short these markets, I’ll also state that anyone who wants to believe all the horse manure about US Treasuries no longer being INTERNATIONALLY REGARDED as the safest and most widely held fixed income paper on the planet, or no longer representing THE best safe haven paper asset there is, or no longer an alternative to stocks when they “fall out of favor” (it’s coming!), or no longer are the PRIMARY fixed income instrument by held by just about every pension fund, bank and insurance company in the USA? Anyone who believes ANY of that is making a big mistake. US TREASURY BONDS ARE THE GLOBAL GOLD STANDARD FOR FIXED INCOME…AND WHEN YOU CAN BUY THEM AT A ROUGHLY 40% DISCOUNT TO WHERE THEY WERE 5 YEARS AGO, THAT’S WHAT YOU DO.

 

I won’t belabor it but I CONTINUE TO BELIEVE THAT EVERYBODY IS BASICALLY CONTENTEDLY LONG EVERYTHING…HOT STOCKS, CRYPTO, PRECIOUS METALS, COMMODITIES---TO AN EXTENT THAT I’D CALL IT “COMPLACENTLY BULLISH”---And in this investing MOB PSYCHOLOGY GAME, THAT SORT OF FAIRLY UNANIMOUS “BLASÉ” BULLISH ATTITUDE USUALLY LEADS TO AN ALWAYS TOTALLY UNEXPECTED “CRAP OUT.” So yeah, I remain of the opinion that big sell offs are coming in all of those areas…And that the market “nobody” is in, US Treasuries, are going up from here…and BIG.

 

WHY SELL STOCKS HERE?

 

Very briefly, I basically think the economy is in serious trouble, mostly as a function of the policies and actions of Herr Trump’s disassembling just about everything there is in the country: Cutting services, killing jobs, killing entire departments, killing crop prices, scaring cheap labor (NECESSARY to any number of industries) into hiding or running out of the country, destroying just about EVERY diplomatic relationship we’ve had with our longstanding Allies, and then the moronically SENSELESS Tariff Thing, which in NO way is a positive for domestic and internationally trade (including all the threats, extremes, and of course, the abrupt reversals)…has left the CEO’s of this country’s biggest companies in shock…paralyzed because nobody knows what’s coming…while at the same time, the average consumer is choking on high prices at the grocery store and everything else they buy…and this is with the tariff’s effects JUST beginning to kick in, whether it’s at Walmart, Wendy’s, Home Depot or anywhere else…I could go on and on in great detail but I’ll just leave it at this: Paralyzed CEO’s, and business people at any level, is NOT conducive to growth. Nor is it conducive to spending when consumers ARE choking on prices in every aspect of their lives. Nor are the very REAL job losses (that Trump delusionally denies) indicative of growth. And finally, it belies an absolutely total ignorance of history to suppose that SENDING THE ARMY INTO THE STREETS is at all a good thing in a democratic economy.

 

And no, I DON’T know where everything is headed…but I CAN’T HELP BUT THINK THAT ANY INVESTMENT IN STOCKS, CRYPTO OR PRECIOUS METALS HERE COULD BE SERIOUSLY UNDERWATER 3-6 MONTHS FROM NOW.

 

 

GETTING BACK TO THE REAL REASON FOR THIS NEWSLETTER…BUYING THE INTEREST RATE MARKETS…

 

Take another look at those Commitments of Traders and Open Interest charts above…and be fully aware of just how historically, and incredibly short, the Speculative Funds are…And then note on the next chart that they MUST already be showing losses…pretty much across the board.

 

Here’s where I am taking positions…in the two contracts that will move the biggest…I’d say do both, or either one. It doesn’t matter…JUST DO THIS…when “nobody else” is…

 

 

Hell of a trade I think…Last thought would be to remind you that there ARE two major paper investment instruments. One is STOCKS. The other is BONDS…They BOTH have their periodic days in the sun. And for as long as I’ve been doing this business, when everybody loves one of them, and “hates” the other…IS when you jump on the “other.”

 

Lots of ways to do this…And I have to add that these options look as cheap as I have ever seen them in the Treasury market.

 

Thanks if you read all this…and if you did, and you “get it,” DO call and do something with it.

 

Thanks,

Bill

 

770-425-7241

866-578-1001

 

All option prices in this newsletter include all fees and commissions. All charts, unless otherwise noted, are by Aspen Graphics and CRB.

 

FUTURES TRADING IS NOT FOR EVERYONE. THE RISK OF LOSS IN TRADING CAN BE SUBSTANTIAL. THEREFORE, CAREFULLY CONSIDER WHETHER SUCH TRADING IS SUITABLE FOR YOU IN LIGHT OF YOUR FINANCIAL CONDITION. PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS. THERE IS NO GUARANTEE YOUR TRADING EXPERIENCE WILL BE SIMILAR TO PAST PERFORMANCE.

 

The author of this piece currently trades for his own account and has a financial interest in the following derivative products mentioned within: Notes and Bonds, Feeder Cattle and Live Cattle